Standard(s) oklahoma academic standards c3 social studies (2012) analyze the impact of leading industrialists as “robber barons” and as “ philanthropists” including john d rockefeller and andrew carnegie and his gospel of wealth essay on american society. Some nineteenth-century industrialists who were called “captains of industry” overlap with those called “robber barons,” however these include people such as jp morgan, andrew carnegie, andrew w mellon, and john d rockefeller the positive term was coined by thomas carlyle in his 1843 book, past and present. It's a mixed bag, but i tend to come down on the side of their being robber barons it wasn't that their philanthropy wasn't significant or that some of them didn't work their way up from the bottom (carnegie), it's that the wealth they amassed was done so on the backs of ordinary workers, and at a gigantic human cost. Wealth, more commonly known as the gospel of wealth, is an article written by andrew carnegie in june of 1889 that describes the responsibility of philanthropy by the new upper class of self-made rich carnegie proposed that the best way of dealing with the new phenomenon of wealth inequality was for the wealthy to. Read this full essay on andrew carnegie and john d rockefeller andrew carnegie and john d rockefeller captains of industry, or robber barons.
The term “robber baron” is one that has been used for many years to describe american capitalists from the late 19th century who used questionable as well as less than ethical methods to attain their wealth jp morgan, john d rockefeller and andrew carnegie were all very wealthy americans who have had this term. But many questioned whether america should view these three men as captains of industry or robber barons (who are john d rockefeller, andrew carnegie, cornelius vanderbilt, were all big business leaders in the 19th century do you have at least a rough outline for the entire essay/paper. Each witness will turn in a written statement in essay or research outline form ( to be admitted in evidence) your written grade will be based on this you've now spent several days determining whether andrew carnegie was a captain of industry or robber baron, saint or sinner through that trial process, you.
Cornelius vanderbilt, john d rockefeller, andrew carnegie jp morgan, henry ford – their names are early on, showing that captains of industry will always be chal- lenged by new innovators and mavericks thomas nast created cartoons criticizing the robber barons for their role conflicts in the railroad industry wars. The period of invention after the civil war set the stage for immense industrial growth (cayton 237) this period of time in the late 1800's is known as the industrial revolution two prominent names in big business were john d rockefeller and andrew carnegie there is no doubt that these people left their. America wasn't discovered, it was built by a group of business-savvy, innovative young men: john d rockefeller, cornelius vanderbilt, andrew carnegie, henry ford, jp morgan and thomas edison explore the lives of america's first captains of industry on biographycom.
Andrew carnegie essay in the nineteenth century, when i hear the word captain of industry the name andrew carnegie comes to mind rather than being a robber baron, i believe carnegie deserves the title captain of industry for many reasons one reason would be that he came from being a poor young boy in scotland,. Although many people believe the early industrialists were robber barons who exploited the poor, these great men were truly captains of industry who created new ways of doingshow more content although some of these criticisms are well founded, men like andrew carnegie and john d rockefeller were, in fact. Stories about andrew carnegie's life and robber baron as american hero, libraries across america, autobiography, the gospel of wealth with links to essays & literary criticism and analysis.
The scottish-born american industrialist and philanthropist andrew carnegie ( 1835-1919) was one of the first captains of industry the era has sometimes been called the age of the robber barons on the assumption that because no public regulation or direction existed large fortunes were built by unprincipled men. Robber baronvscaptain of industryjohn d rockefeller was the guiding force behind the creation of the standard oil company, which grew to dominate the oil industry this company was one of the first big trusts in the united states, thus much controve.